Lafayette Market Square

The Best Pizza In Town

7” Cheese – 4.99 | 10” Cheese – 6.99 | 14” Cheese – 10.99

7” toppings – .50 | 10” toppings – 1.00 | 14” toppings – 1.50


Sausage, Mushrooms, Ground Pepperoni, Onions, Green Peppers, Jalapeños, Tomato, Extra Cheese*, Chicken*, Ham, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Fresh Broccoli, Bacon, Pineapple, Anchovies, Spicy Sausage*

*Extra Charge

Please note there is a 3.00 up charge on our 10″ gluten free dough

Arni’s Open Faced Classics


Thinly sliced ham and breast of turkey on toast, ladled with a creamy cheese sauce and sprinkled with chopped tomato, green onions and bits of real bacon. – 7.49

Reuben á la Arni

Arni’s version of the classic! Corned beef and sauerkraut on rye, blanketed with melted Swiss, then crowned with diced Roma tomatoes, Dijon mustard and drizzled with Thousand Island dressing. – 8.29

Smoked Turkey Reuben

Sliced smoked turkey breast with creamy cole slaw, Swiss cheese, tomato and a drizzle of Thousand Island dressing on rye toast. – 7.49

Sunshine Crab Melt

Our signature crab salad on fresh garlic toast and topped with tomato, green onion and melted cheddar.  – 7.49

Tuna Supreme

Delicious homemade tuna salad on fresh garlic toast, topped with tomatoes, green onion and melted mozzarella. – 7.49

The Nightmare

Kosher style corned and pepper beef on white toast, topped with Dijon mustard, sauerkraut, green onions and a creamy cheese sauce.  – 8.29

BBQ Buckaroo

Slices of delicious prime rib on toast, topped with savory BBQ, onions, green peppers and cheddar. – 8.29


New Yorker Combo

Choose any two of our fresh deli meats, one cheese, and your choice of bread. Garnished with lettuce, tomato, hard boiled egg, and served with 1000 Island dressing and your choice of cole slaw or potato salad – 7.99


Select from these delicious items and create your own masterpiece – Ask your server for pricing.

Meats – Baked Ham, Smoked Turkey Breast, Thin Sliced Prime Rib, Hard Salami, and Lean Corned Beef

Spreads – Tuna Salad, Crabmeat Salad and Smoked Chicken Salad

Cheeses – American, Swiss, Sliced Cheddar, and Pepper Jack

Breads – White, Wheat, Rye, Kaiser Bun, Croissant

Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce

That says it all-except for how delicious it really is! – 7.29

Spaghetti With Meatballs

Our killer meatballs made with Italian sausage and ground beef, marinara sauce and Parmesan cheese. – 7.99

Chili Spaghetti

Our spicy chili poured over a bed of spaghetti and topped with onions and lots of cheddar cheese. – 7.59

Chicken Fettuccine

Tender strips of chicken, broccoli florets and sliced mushrooms tossed
with fettuccine noodles and Alfredo sauce. – 7.99

Deep-Dish Meat Lasagna

Pasta ribbons layered with savory Italian meat sauce, mozzarella and ricotta cheeses than baked to bubbling goodness. – 9.49

Chicken Pasta Parmesan

Mouth watering strips of chicken over spaghetti, smothered with our marinara sauce and loads of mozzarella cheese – 8.29

Soup and Salad

A cup of today’s soup and Arni’s Junior Salad with your choice of dressing  – 7.59

Soup & Half Sandwich

A cup of today’s hot soup and half club sandwich – 7.59

Pizza and Salad

A small tossed salad and 7” pizza with your choice of two toppings – 7.99

Chocolate Lovin’ Spoonful

A giant mouthful of chocolate pudding between two layers of moist, chocolate-drenched chocolate cake. – 4.99

Peanut Butter Thundercake

Chocolate cake layered with crushed Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups and covered in peanut butter frosting. – 4.99


Richest and creamiest! Ask for selections. – 4.59

Oreo® Brownie Blast

An Oreo brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, Oreo crumbs and whipped cream – 4.99


Baked daily. Choose from peanut butter or chocolate chip – .85  each

Sweet Surprise

Ask your server what’s on special today!